Showing posts with label Week 2. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Week 2. Show all posts

Sunday, February 8, 2015

Storytelling Week 2: The Cruelty of Achilles

Now Achilles was in mourning over his friend Patroclus, still, though he had just slain the mighty Hector. His anger towards the Trojans burned deep within him, for Patroclus had been his dearest friend. The glory of taking Troy would be his, yes, but at what cost? His soldiers viewed him as a leader, a warrior, but hardly as a friend like dear Patroclus had. After he had dispatched Hector, Achilles had dragged him behind his chariot, his mare effortlessly gliding across the plain in front of the wall as the lifeless body of Hector dragged behind him.

Atop the wall, King Priam had watched as his noblest son was humiliated in death. He was both angered by Achilles' actions and saddened because no man could avenge his son against the mightiest of warriors. He paced thoughtfully, wondering how he could possibly retrieve Hector's body to give him a proper burial. 

Meanwhile, the gods had convened to watch Achilles' battle with Hector. When they saw him take the body back to the Greek camp, Zeus became angry with Achilles.

"Go to your son at once," Zeus commanded Thetis, "And tell him it is my wish that he return the body of Hector to the Trojans."


         Thetis listening to Zeus' commands for Achilles.

So Thetis made hastily for the shores of Troy where Achilles had taken the body of Hector. "My son, you must allow Hector the proper burial," she said. "Zeus has sworn his wrath upon you if you refuse. Listen to what the king Priam will offer for ransom." Achilles reluctantly agreed.

The king loaded up his chariot with the finest jewels, trinkets and cloaks he could find. At high noon the following day, he ordered the gates of the mighty wall open and made his way to the Grecian camp. Achilles had awoken with the sun, his mourning over Patroclus robbing him of peaceful slumber. He waited patiently for the king to arrive to hear his proposition. In no time, the king had entered the camp.

Soliders led the king to Achilles' tent, for they had heard the night before of his intentions. Achilles ushered the soldiers out so the two men could discuss in solitude. Priam's offer was simple: keep the chariot and everything in it, but give him Hector's body intact so as not to refuse him the burial he deserves. As he was listening to Priam's offer, Achilles mind began to wander back to Patroclus' death. He recalled the Trojans spearing him in the back, and taking Achilles' arms from his body. A fiery urge for vengeance crept into his belly, and Achilles became incensed. 

"No amount of gold or jewels can bring back my closest friend," Achilles explained. "Therefore, no amount of gold or jewels will bring back your proudest son."

Zeus had been watching intently as Achilles and Priam conversed, and soon became furious with Achilles' disobedience. He sent down a crack of lightning just outside Achilles' tent as a warning for the mistake he was about to make. But proud as he was, Achilles paid it no mind. He left the tent in a rage.

He went outside to where Hector’s body was laid, grabbed his sword and cut the limbs of the body, furthering the prince’s humiliation in death. Once he had spent all of his anger, he grabbed a torch and lit the body where it was, completely destroying the chance for a proper burial. Priam watched in despair as the remains of his son rose towards the gods in a plume of black smoke. 

As soon as he was done, he fled. Thetis, though she wished not to anger Zeus, hid her son as he ran, for she loved him dearly. Achilles wasn’t seen for many years, and the Greeks suffered a tragic defeat at the hands of the Trojans, for they had no warrior who could match Achilles’ strength and leadership. 


Author’s Note: I used “The Ransoming of Hector” as the basis for my story. Instead of Priam getting his son back, however, I put forth a scenario in which Achilles refused his offer, thus risking the wrath of Zeus. This is a critical point to consider when reading my story, as Zeus is all-powerful to the Greek people. To anger him is to almost certainly be inviting death, one way or another. I think my version highlights different attributes of Achilles, not only his anger, but his belief that he wouldn't be defeated by anybody, even Zeus. In the original, Achilles accepts the ransom of gold and jewels, and the Greeks and Trojans have a 9 day respite from battle to give Hector a proper burial. This is an important part of Greek culture in the setting of Troy vs. the Greeks, as a proper burial allows the deceased to be given coins to pay the ferry toll. I doubt Achilles would have ever done what I said he did just because while he is a fierce warrior, he does respect the traditions of his people and their enemies, but in my interpretation, Achilles is a slave to his anger a lot more than he is in The Iliad. 



Sunday, January 25, 2015

Mythology Storyboard Topics

Topic: Dogs in ancient myths and legends
Comments: Dogs are revered in many differrent cultures, from Egypt to the British Isles and even in today's society (by some people). I'd like to look into how dogs have been portrayed across the different cultures over time. 

Possible stories: One story I noticed was "The Martyred Hound" in the British Isles section. I think stories regarding Anubis would be good for this section as well. 

Story Comments: In the Martyred Hound, the Prince's hound is treated like family. He goes on hunts, looks after the prince's son, etc. But he ends up killing the hound in vain, and burying him. Stories like these that explain why places are called what they are would be an interesting concept I think.

Story Source: The Martyred Hound
The Welsh Fairy Book 
W. Jenkyn Thomas with illustrations by Willy Pogány 
(1908)

Topic: Dante's Inferno
Comments: I've always had a fascination with how Dante portrayed Hell. The idea of "Hell" was hotly debated during the early 2nd millenium, as it still is. Dante's creativity in storytelling has been studied extensively, and still people study him to find more from what he was trying to say. I've read through some of the cantos he wrote before, but never fully finished it. 

Possible Stories: Since Dante's Inferno is one big story, I'd have to choose a section to focus on. I think the section of Fallen Angels would be a good focus point, or even something as broad as the final 3 rings that hold the worst sinners.  

Story comments: I read through the section on Fallen Angels and was a bit disappointed to see a lack of any angels mentioned by name. I thought I remembered seeing some last time I read (or attempted to read) the Inferno, but I guess I was wrong. Nonetheless, it's an interesting topic because Dante does a great job of creating a human element in that section especially by demonstrating his fears or worries.

Story Source: The Fallen Angels

Topic: Alice in Wonderland

Comments: Alice in Wonderland is such an interesting story because of the fantastical aspects of it. There have been many adaptations, film and otherwise, and I think a project from the view of the Mad Hatter could allow for a lot of creativity. 

Possible Stories: The same thing I would have to do for Dante's Inferno I would have to do for this I imagine, pick a specific section. Like I mentioned, I think a project from the Mad Hatter's point of view would create an interesting narrative, one that could change the way this story is perceived. 

Story Comments: I read through the story "A Mad Tea-Party" and noticed it's quite a puzzling section. The use of riddles and questions with no answers is such an interesting narrative to me. The dialogue is strange, which, again, would add up to some interesting dialogue opportunities from a different perspective. I think I could create some ridiculous things that would make perfect sense in the Mad Hatter's thought process. 

Story Source: "A Mad Tea-Party"
Alice's Adventures in Wonderland  
Lewis Carroll 
(1865)

Topic: Japanese Myths

Comments: Having been to Japan, I learned quite a bit about their culture, beliefs and daily happenings. But what I didn't learn about was their myths and legends (well, besides the obvious ones). I'd love to dig deeper into the aspects of Japanese culture that attempted to explain the unexplainable. 

Possible Stories: I think the stories focusing on snakes or dragons would be the best ones to adapt into stories. Dragons and serpents play such an integral role in Japanese culture, so finding a way to tell a story from their perspective could make for an interesting project. 

Story Comments: The story I chose was "The Eight-Forked Serpent of Koshi" because of the serpent/dragon connection. The use of gods as "regular people" stood out to me as odd because usually gods are portrayed as all-powerful, all-knowing, etc. I'm curious if other Japanese myths have the same dynamic between the gods as this one did. 

Illustration from Romance of Old Japan (sourced below)

Story Source: Romance of Old Japan 
E. W. Champney and F. Champney 
(1917)

Thursday, January 22, 2015

Aesop for Children (Winter): Extra Reading Diary

Although I love Greek mythology, I remember having the book of Aesop's Fables as a kid. The stories were always simple but packed a valuable message. Reading through them again, I got the same impression I did all those years ago. Here's what I thought of a few of the stories from the first half of the unit.

The first story I liked a lot was the "Tortoise and the Ducks." The tortoise loses his life because he opens his mouth to tell the crow he is the king of the tortoises, even though the ducks told him not to or he'd be sorry. The moral of the story is not to let foolish curiosity and vanity in your life because they often lead to misfortune. This is a valuable lesson (like most of Aesop's fables) to humans because all too often being too proud or curious can get us into trouble, in more ways than one. 

The next one I thought was good was "The Boy and the Filberts." He gets his hand stuck in a jar trying to get them, when all he has to do is take fewer at a time. The moral of this story is don't try to do too much at once. This is especially relevant to college students, particularly during finals week. We're all guilty of putting off studying until the night before the test and trying to cram everything in at one time. If we had studied in small sections over the course of the week (even though that's hard to do sometimes), we probably wouldn't be so exhausted during finals week!

"The Farmer and the Stork" is a story that especially stuck out to me. In it, the stork went with a party of cranes and got into some trouble in the farmer's field. He pleaded with the farmer to let him go, for he was a member of an honest and trustworthy family. But since he was with the cranes, the farmer told him he would receive the same punishments as them. You are judged by the company you keep is the moral of the story and something we should all be wary of. You could be the nicest, most honest person in the world, but if you hang out with the wrong crowd, people will automatically judge you as a bad person almost every time. 



Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Homer's Iliad: Reading Diary B

The beginning of the second half of the unit starts with "The Rousing of Achilles," which recounts the battle for Patroclus' body. I found it extremely interesting because it kind of shows how important wartime customs were to the Greeks and Trojans. Sometimes they would leave the body for the enemy to bury, but other times they would take their arms, I assume as a sort of humiliation for defeat. I also found it interesting that the greatest god of all, Zeus, had such an interest in this particular battle.

The story also shows the grace of the gods shown towards Achilles. He has no armor, so his mother says she will get Hephaestus to make some for him. Not many warriors have that sort of connection with the gods.

In "The Slaying of Hector," I found it even more interesting that Apollo willfully intervened in the battle. Achilles could easily slain Agenor (I'm not sure how to do the accent mark above the "e") had Apollo not protected him. It doesn't seem very fair for a mortal to have to contend with an immortal as powerful as Apollo. In the continuation, the gods meet to decide if Hector should be able to live or be forced to die, as fate had condemned him to do. The humanity of the gods seems rather odd, as it seems like they would have no interest in mere men.

Once Achilles slays Hector, his care for Patroclus becomes apparent. He doesn't even consider giving Hector's body back to the Trojans; he only wants his body to be destroyed completely. Even after the offer of riches, Achilles only cares for vengeance and glory.

The story ends with "The Ransoming of Hector." Although Achilles had no intention of giving Hector's body back, once he learned that Zeus wanted Priam to have his son's body, he agreed to give it back. I found it very interesting that Priam would give up so much gold and jewels just to have his son's body back to bury it. It really showed how much emphasis was put on proper burials to prepare for the afterlife in that time period.


Priam pleads Achilles for Hector's body in this painting by Carl Probsthayn.

Homer's Iliad: Reading Diary A

The first story that I really liked from The Iliad unit was "The Quarrel." It introduces Achilles as the hero trying to help Agamemnon get Helen of Troy back. This second portion of the story demonstrates Agamemnon's greed and unwillingness to do whatever necessary to get Helen back, and also displays Achilles' connection to the gods. Achilles' proclivity for battle is also shown, as Agamemnon comments that Achilles has no idea of law and order, but only of battle. The only thing he cares about is the cry of battle.

The next story I found interesting was "Hector and Andromache." Homer does a great job of showing the strengths and weaknesses of Hector and Paris, Hector being the proud, courageous warrior willing to fight for his country, and Paris being the not-so-courageous one scared of defeat. Hector is also portrayed as a family man, hoping that one day his son will be called a better man than he ever was.

"The Embassy to Achilles," which was in two parts, shows the pride of Achilles. Since Agamemnon had taken his share of the riches, he refuses to assist in the taking of Troy any further. He says Agamemnon could offer him twenty times as much as he already had, and he would still refuse. Although Achilles is famous for his wartime prowess, he is not an idiot. And he makes it very clear in this story he answers to no one who scorns him. This section also emphasizes the faith the Greeks had in their gods; Achilles partially refuses to fight because Zeus is on the Trojans' side.

The final part of the first half of the unit, "The Deeds and Death of Patroclus," tells us of Patroclus asking to borrow Achilles' armor so that he may lead the Greeks into battle. Achilles agrees, but says that Patroclus must not conquer the city of Troy, as the glory for that conquest must go to him. This portion drives home the pride of Achilles; the only thing he truly cares about is fame.


Though not from the first half of the unit, this picture, painted by Franz Matsch, sums up Achilles pretty well; bold, proud, and a ferocious warrior.